The Elder Scrolls Online – Beta Impressions



By Michael Sagoe (mikedot)

There is certainly a lot of buzz regarding the release for one of the biggest MMORPGs of the year: The Elders Scrolls Online (ESO) is the latest chapter in the long running RPG series that started way back in 1994. Set before the events of the previous titles including Skyrim, Oblivion and Morrowind, ESO promises to carry on the same non-linear exploration and gameplay that made the series so popular. However due to the nature of modern MMORPGs, many fans of the series have expressed their concerns since the very first announcement of the game. Many others are left skeptical whether or not Zenimax will be able to pull it off just right, including myself, so I attended the press event with uncertainty.

ESO

Keep in mind that I am not too familiar with the series as a whole, so I will not be able to say much regarding story content and lore consistency. Instead, my impressions will mainly be focused on gameplay, pace of progression and the alliance war feature.

Starting off with the initial character creation, players can choose between nine different races between three different alliances: Daggerfall Covenent races include Bretons, Redguards and Orcs. Ebonheart Pact races include Nords, Dark Elves and Argonians.  Lastly, Aldmeri Dominion races include High Elves, Wood Elves and Khajiits. As my character choice, I wanted to play as the manliest looking race in the bunch, so I decided to go with a rugged Nord.

There’s is a decent amount of character creation options available, including various selections for facial shaping, body mass adjustments via a triangular adjustor, skin color, hair style and more, all complete with sliders for some fine tuning. However, despite all these available options, the customization feels a bit restrictive, mainly due to how limited players are with the slider values. Of course, I wasn’t expecting an extensive character creation system (on the same level as, say… All Points Bulletin or Blade & Soul), but I couldn’t help but feel that it would be far too easy for players to unintentionally create clones and look-alikes within every player’s chosen gender and race.

Nord

After character creation, players can then choose their starting class, including Dragonknight, Sorcerer, Nightlblade and Templar. Each class has their own skill lines so players can spec themselves for different play styles, which sounds all well and good, but later on I would find the systems tied to this to be surprisingly limited. So for my class choice, I went with the Dragonknight so I could focus on up-close melee combat.

Once my character was all set, I was dropped into a dark prison cave all by my lonesome, until a strange figure appeared named “The Prophet,” who would then help me escape the cave with other prisoners. Here, I would get my first taste of ESO’s combat. And it was a taste that was incredibly sour and would last throughout my entire playing experience.

The core combat mechanics are fairly straightforward, as pressing LMB performs basic attacks and holding RMB performs blocks. Players can hold the LMB to perform heavy attacks and hold RMB before pressing LMB to perform shoves and interrupts.

ESO

The first gripe I had with the combat was with how unsatisfying melee combat felt, as every hit lacked a sense of impact. Subtle animation and visual tricks such as camera shakes and hitpauses could have gone a long way to making melee combat feel visceral, but ESO failed to accomplish this on multiple levels. It wasn’t until around level eight when I unlocked my uppercut skill that I was actually given an attack that actually felt good to perform, as the attack knocks enemies off the ground.

Another issue with combat was the fact that it used pseudo-non targeting (also known as soft targeting) as certain skills could not be performed until an enemy is highlighted over the player’s crosshair, so if there’s a moment where the player would like to use their combat skills in an unconventional way, such as using a leaping strike in order to avoid enemy fire, it simply won’t be possible.

(NOTE - 2/16/2014: It has been brought to my attention recently that ESO allows players to switch between two weapons sets of the player's choosing, allowing them to bring a second skill set along in the process. This article has been slightly updated to include this detail.)

Now, I’m personally fond of accessibility and simplicity, but ESO takes this way too far by only allowing a limited number of skills that can be used at a time per battle, which will inevitably make combat feel repetitive early on. I mean sure, games such as Guild Wars and the upcoming WildStar have similar systems with limited action sets, but just for fun: Let us compare each of these games with the amount of active skills available to the player:

ESO
Guild Wars 2: Five skills (among two weapon sets) for weapon abilities and five other skills separated by one for healing, three for utility and one elite skill. (Up to 15 skills available per battle.)

ESO
WildStar: Eight skills for assault, support and utility, one for path skills, one for gadget skills and one innate skill among two stance sets.

Now taking a looking at what ESO has available...

ESO
ESO: Five slots for combat, support, buff skills and one ultimate skill (among two weapon sets.)

With these direct comparisons, you can see just how limited things are with how ESO handles the limited action set approach. It's nice that players can switch between those weapons on the fly in ESO, but with only six skills usable at a time, several skills coming off as too similar to each other, and some of which cannot be used in unconventional ways,  it still comes off as lacking.

The reason they wanted it this way is mostly contributed to the fact that the developers want to make this game accessible enough for home consoles, which personally is a horrid idea for even the most casual of MMO players out there. If it was up to me, I would rather have those home console players stick a mouse and keyboard into their consoles, rather than sticking everyone with a dumbed down combat scheme.

So with all that said, I can drop the rant and focus back on the questing in ESO. After escaping the prison, players are free to roam around a village on a snowy Island. My time spent on that island was mainly filled with typical fetch and kill quests, one after another, until I was able to leave the island after completing a critical story quest. The early questing experience fails to give me any real sense of freedom or exploration, as ESO’s leveling progression pretty much dictates where I can go and what I can do, more so than any other modern MMO I’ve played.

ESO

After I was able to leave the island, complete a few more quests and painstakingly grind my way to LV10, it was time for me to try out the game’s alliance war mode, which was one of the major highlights during the press event. For anyone that has ever played World vs. World vs. World mode in Guild Wars 2, you’ll know almost instantly what alliance war is all about: Players will fight over towns, farms, castles and resources in an attempt to control the continent of Cyrodiil.

ESO

Starting out in my alliance castle, players in my alliance were already getting prepared for battle, with our first attack set out on a nearby fort owned by the Aldmeri Dominion, which already had 70% control over the map. As some players were explaining finer details of battle, others were busy trying to attack the well-guarded fort only using ballista cannons and catapults. It was a long task trying to take the fort door down, but we managed to do it with very little interference from the enemy. Once we got inside, a player instructed others to use battering rams instead of other siege weapons. After a bit of an impromptu boot camp on siege weapon use, our fort attacks started going a lot smoother.

ESO

We managed to bust down the inner fort door in record time, fully capturing the fortification in minutes. Afterwards, everyone purchased some repair kits in order to fix all the damage we had done to the fort before heading off to the next one. We continued on our merry way expecting some sort of resistance, but three more forts fell without a single peep from the Elven scum and their cronies. Yet in an inconspicuous looking farmland, the enemy alliance finally let us feel their presence. An entire army from the Aldmeri Dominion appeared out of nowhere and ambushed us, leaving most of us dead where we were, forced to watch the rest of the battle in ghost vision.

ESO

Of course, we didn’t want to take it lying down, so we tried launching our own ambush. The , Aldmeri Dominion was looking to take back one of our captured farms, so we all ran off to the spot and tried hiding away from plain sight.

ESO

Once they arrived, we sprang into action and tried to beat them at their own game, but ultimately failed as they continued to push on. But unfortunately for me: my time was up, and that was end of my ESO press test experience. I managed to strike someone down just as I had to split.

ESO

While my time spent playing around during the Alliance War was fun, it was the only enjoyable part of my entire ESO experience. Everything else about the game seems to be too accessible and simplistic for my taste, so I’m very uncertain over how much lasting appeal ESO will have for anyone that isn’t a diehard fan of the Elders Scroll series. With reports of the game having no open beta test for the public, it only worries me further regarding how well ESO will do in the long run.

Social Media :

Comments

  • Duane Freeman

    Oh wow you are reporting the same lame crap that most of those negative idiots have been reporting for weeks. And not looking at the bigger picture at all. How sad good thing I don’t listen to moron reviews like this one. You should stay away from MMOs.

    • Michael Sagoe

      “Oh wow you are reporting the same lame crap that most of those negative idiots have been reporting for weeks.”

      Not exactly. I’m reporting MY experience on the game, clear and simple. It just so happens that my experience was very similar to those that also feel the same way about the game.

      “And not looking at the bigger picture at all.”

      What is this “bigger picture” that you speak of, then? The endgame? The grand story? Whatever it is, I’d like to hear it, because so far, others have insisted that the alliance war feature will be ESO’s saving grace, making the game completely worth the $59.99 dollar price tag + $14.99 monthly fee, which I find is ridiculous. As much as I enjoyed the alliance war, I had a case of “been there, done that”.

      Lastly, my article was not a review. It was an IMPRESSIONS article. A first look. It’s certainly not an end-all be-all opinion on the game, since the game is (techincally) still in beta form and things about the game CAN change by the time the ESO launches. And I certainly hope it does, because it’s going to need a lot of changes if Bethesda is going to justify that price tag.

  • Synns

    Must say I’m glad of the limited skills bar, if I had my way there would be no skills bar at all and it would be set up very simply just like other elder scrolls games. Dc online is another game that has very limited skill bars and I personally find that system far nicer than the typical mmo hundreds of skills approach.
    I will agree with one point though, the combat has no weight. It does feel like your just hitting thin air and this is something that defiantly must be fixed, especially with such a simple combat system.

    • Michael Sagoe

      ” if I had my way there would be no skills bar at all and it would be set up very simply just like other elder scrolls games.”

      I understand where you’re coming from, but at that point, it would make me wonder why they even bothered to turn ESO into an MMORPG in the first place. They should have made ESO into an MORPG in the vein of other online games like Phantasy Star Online or Monster Hunter, where players meet up in a town, group up and then go out to venture the world. This would have been much better to help ESO along story-wise, since they’ll be able to keep the single-player adventure feel in fact.

  • Georg Satyros

    Well, I stopped reading as soon as I reached the “6 skills only, buhuhu*cry*. ” part. Wrong. You have 6 skills per weapon, with the ability to switch weapons on the fly.
    So.. 12 skills. And then you can change those two weapons from encounter to encounter. Be a rogue now and a wizard in the next fight. This adds a lot of depth in combat. A fact that you “missed” in your review.
    I keep saying this over and over. STOP missinforming, stop randomly accusing.
    ESO has a million flaws, but next to noone is bothering with them. They focus on nonsense like the text above.

    • http://fanhelix.com/ Michael Sagoe

      And again, I must point out: This is a “first look” impressions article, not a review. The only reason the article tag says it’s a review is because we do not have a proper tag for impressions or preview articles. I had a very limited amount of time available to try out the game, so I was not able to try out every single element and/or gameplay feature that was available in ESO.

      But I will accept that the details regarding skills usage is misleading due since you mentioned that weapon switching is possible. I’ll speak with the editors soon to see if I can have these details in the articles updated.