Free MMORPG Forums

Jacksterson

So the fan site: www.dbthemovie.com asked me to make a logo for them.

__________________

Serix

i feel bad for them, srsly.

__________________

Jacksterson

...srsly, Serix. I know you think of yourself as a critic, but somehow I think you fail in that criteria. Just because theres no c4d's, just because theres no shiny things in the background, or because theres no renders, or because I use pre-rendered brushes (WHICH btw, is what they were made for), does not mean that every single thing I do is crap.

A true critic, a GOOD critic, wouldn't let his own biases get in the way of his judgement.

__________________

daroth

You can be more creative than that can't you? Seems bland, imo.

__________________

Jakuza

Seems fine to me.

__________________

Greed

Agreed. I don't see what's wrong with it.

__________________

Serix

Now looky here mr goose, I gave no mention about the bland details and the failed simplicity in this, or the lack of texture on the planet, lack of proper lighting and color depth. Simply because I've given up hope that you may have any sort of talent. As a critic, I'm harsh, but I'm true, I tell them what I feel is missing, and truth be told, I hardly use c4d's or have overtly glossed backgrounds, in fact, simple is what I am for when I design. When I say something is crap, which is exactly what I was implying by my first post, I normally explain why, I don't bother with you because you really have no latent talent or hope of improvement.

Now onto your more failed arguments, when have I ever complained about a lack of renders? never. I may complain that the render isn't properly resized, the render itself and its placement, but never about a lack thereof. Pre-made brushes were made for learning, the more "expert" photoshoppers use their own brushes or customized brushes.

I can continue giving you a lesson on how much you fail but I doubt that would change anything.

And I, as a true, good critic, do not let my biases get in the way, when I feel there's room for improvement, because in the end, knowing when to tell someone to give up, is the best trait a critic may have.

Good day, failure.

__________________

TheWiseGuy

yep agreed as well.....seems perfectly fine to me......sometimes simplicity makes things pretty sexy

__________________

GoFlyAKite

Looks ok, I don't like the left side of the planet though.

__________________

Target_Practice

The banner is fine.
Simplicity fits this sort of thing.

Not everything has to be so stuffed with C4D or effects that it looks unappealing to everyone but the "Hardcore Graphics Community"