http://img105.imageshack.us/img105/2913/simplecleanjw0.jpg
My best sig ever IMO. The scribble pencil thing didn't turn out exactly as I wanted, but meh. Comments and ratings (1-10) please.

Its nice, it has focal. But there is hardly any depth it seems washed out. I wouldnt say its your best. I like your halloween one much more. It just seems more composed.

Here I am looking at the sig, wondering what to type and I scroll down to see availer pretty much summing it up. 8.5/10 tho.

Its nice, it has focal. But there is hardly any depth it seems washed out. I wouldnt say its your best. I like your halloween one much more. It just seems more composed.
You really like the halloween one more? Surprising i thought this one was way better. Guess I keep working. Thanks guys. ^^

You said my sig was a shame *crys* I feel so disheartened. Why the pain..

no much going on just a face, it doesnt say nothing to me.

7.9/10

Thats not your best IMO. I like sigs with a lot going on but that doesn't have any thing going on really. Theres too much space left.

Thats not your best IMO. I like sigs with a lot going on but that doesn't have any thing going on really. Theres too much space left.
The point was to make it a little less busy, because I was afraid of putting to much in it. But I see your point. I guess I can mark this as ONE of my best sigs...at least? Anyway thanks for the comments.

Well, as long as they look snazzy and shiny ^_^.
9/10.

The point was to make it a little less busy, because I was afraid of putting to much in it. But I see your point. I guess I can mark this as ONE of my best sigs...at least? Anyway thanks for the comments.

Sometimes idont want to make it too busy too. Then people complain i left a black space out.

Sometimes idont want to make it too busy too. Then people complain i left a black space out.
Yeah exactly. But everyone's different. I prefer more subtle sigs; ones that focus a lil less on brushes and more on other aspects, like lighting - which is what I attempted with my 2 current sigs. I also really like Availer's current sig, because it isn't too busy or brush-heavy.

hey kareem, i made this in like an hour, then had to patch something i put in the backround so the star fox on the left is a little messed up. (by the way when i said i was gonna beat you in this contest i was KIDDING)

http://img147.imageshack.us/img147/4540/starfoxsig2qp5.png

yeah the star fox cut was way better b4. but then i flattened the layers to put the mosaic filter on (i think it was mosaic, might have been plaster) so on the original it had an ugly plane the backround. so when i went to fix it i didnt have the layers so i had to manually patch it. thats why it looks a bit odd.