Western Mmorpg company that keep the Fatigue system

Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 123
  1. #21
    Manic's Maniacal Machine Reputation: 98

    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Posts
    1,946
    Rep Power
    6

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Technikal View Post
    I have no problems with fatigue systems as long as it's done right.

    I never had a problem with either c9 or DN fatigue system and you could get plenty out of those games each day if you used the fatigue system right.

    I know not everyone likes being forced to stop playing but it's a good thing for players these days.. It also stabilizes economies and makes the time you play more enjoyable. I would rather play a game with less time with way better drops and exp compared to playing all day for bad drops and exp.
    The main thing most (not all) people in western area have with Fatigue system is that they have little appreciation for the game or the dungeons (in a dungeon based game since most fatigue systems occur in these types of games). That being said, they take the unlimited dungeon runs for granted, and when they're forced to limit themselves, they can't find it in them to do so.

    One of the reasons these action MMOs with fatigue systems do so well in the asian countries is because the people have learnt how to deal with the systems, and also have gained a deeper appreciation for the game and the dungeons they run from it. It forces you to think what the best combination of dungeons is to run each day or week, because you are limited. The drops and eventually crafted items feel more rewarding because you've worked hard to get it, not just farmed non stop every day.

    What most western companies fail to do is to implement a fatigue system properly in which the players don't feel that they are being heavily restricted. C9 does a great job with the fatigue system. I wish more games with fatigue systems (and I can see more games switching back to those systems eventually) had systems like it. :P
    Waiting for:

    GTA 5 PC (Pre-Ordered)
    Everquest Next
    [/b]

  2. #22
    Raiyne's Rock Band Reputation: 28
    Exeunt's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Atlanta, GA
    Posts
    2,195
    Rep Power
    9

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Powster View Post
    fatigue system is for bad games that dont have enough content to keep people playing.
    Pretty much this.

  3. #23
    Lives in City of Zeroes Reputation: 106

    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Posts
    649
    Rep Power
    11

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Exeunt View Post
    Pretty much this.
    Well, the thing to keep in mind is, with very, very few exceptions, fatigue systems are in place specifically in action mmorpg's with town hubs so it's not so much that they have 'less content' as that they have 'content which takes less time to go through'.

    Traditional mmorpg's have you spend a lot of time walking; you walk back and forth for quests, you walk back to town if your equipment breaks, you walk back to town if you run out of potions, you walk back to wherever you were if you die (and let's hope you set your home/save/return/checkpoint in the nearest town!), you walk/fly between towns if what you need is only in a specific town (ex: it's not uncommon for skill trainers to only be found at major cities), and you walk to dungeons when you want to party up for some instanced content (and then proceed to wait for the other 4/9/14/24/59+ friends/guild members to walk to said dungeon from wherever they are). It's probably safe to say that at a bare minimum 10 out of every 100 hours a person spends playing a traditional mmorpg is spent simply walks while significantly less travel time is required in a town hub.

    Secondly, traditional mmorpg's tend to have more resting than action mmorpg's (unless they allow for potion spam). This varies a lot from game to game, but in a traditional mmorpg you will almost inevitably spend at least some time simply sitting/standing in place while you watch your HP and MP gradually refill itself (unless, of course, you buy that inevitable cash shop potion which has a separate cooldown timer from other potions) - usually this only takes about 10 seconds to a minute at the absolute most, but again, this adds up over time.

    Lastly, there is the matter of how long party-based content actually takes, especially endgame content. While it is one of the more extreme examples, let's take a look at the rather infamous first raid dungeon of WoW - Molten Core. In this particular dungeon, a group just starting out would need somewhere between 50-60 people (a feat in itself which could easily take a half hour or more just to organize). Boss fights alone take a fair number of minutes, and could easily take an hour+ if the team is inexperienced, but of course the real timesink is in the trash mobs between fights, which are horrendously tedious and respawn after a certain period of time unless their corresponding boss is killed - in all, a 'smooth' run of Molten Core done by a team with appropriate-tier gear (i.e. good enough that they can actually handle it, but not already fully decked out in gear from Molten Core itself or later dungeons) would take roughly 4-6 hours. Now, Molten Core is certainly a bit of a strawman example in terms of quality - it's infamous for a reason after all - but that number of '4-6 hours' tends to be on-par for the average run time of an endgame dungeon in most traditional mmorpg's. Keep in mind also that most pay-to-play mmorpg's (and some free-to-play ones though to a lesser extent) also limit the amount of endgame dungeon runs players are allowed to do to once or twice a week, a restriction which is already arguably far worse than a fatigue system if the game in question puts its focus mainly upon endgame dungeon runs (which most pay-to-play mmorpg's post-WoW do indeed do).

    On the other side of things, action mmorpg's tend to stick to smaller party sizes even for their 'raid' dungeons with a group size of 10 being decidedly on the large side of things (this is likely to limit lag due to all the effects that would be going off with a raid party in the standard 15-20+ size and because it would probably be impossible to make anything out due to said effects, a rather large problem in a game where you need to manually dodge attacks), so there is less time needed to get everyone together and prepare things. In addition, combat moves faster in action mmorpg's and they tend to focus more upon minibosses and bosses in their endgame dungeons than upon trash mobs between boss fights. As a result, a 'long' endgame dungeon in an action mmorpg generally would have a completion time of about 30 minutes, maybe 1 hour if it has some sort of crazy super-boss at the end, which is certainly a far cry from the 4+ hours of an 'average' endgame dungeon. Not to mention, action mmorpg's rarely have other standard endgame timesinks, such as walking around in low level areas looking for plants/ore to gather or grinding up reputation with various factions, so the standard 'once or twice a week' lockout timers on endgame dungeons either simply don't exist, or only take a day or two to expire so players go through these dungeons faster and more often.

    In other words, action mmorpg's have fewer timesinks and shorter dungeons than traditional mmorpg's and fatigue systems are their way of ensuring that players don't blaze through content faster than the developers can create it and the publishers can release it (and when Western publishers *do* remove fatigue systems in games such as DFO and Rusty Hearts, PvP dies and everyone hits the level cap and sits there complaining about content not being released fast enough until they inevitably quit); just because a dungeon in an action mmorpg takes less time to run through and prepare for, it does not mean that it takes less time to develop.

    Now, as for people who only get one or two days a week to play a game in a huge block, it is a 'true' complaint that the fatigue systems work against you, but I do not think it is necessarily a 'valid' complaint. To put it simply, mmorpg's are a business and their primary purpose is making money and to make money they need to have at least some sort of 'target audience'. People who only can play a game for a large chunk of time on one or two days and who are interested neither in making alts nor in participating in PvP are simply not the target audience for most fatigue system games (unless a company aims to make money off of its fatigue system, at which point the quality of the game itself is usually hurt by the system rather than strengthened by it), much as people who can play just about any day, but only at a specific time and only for 1-2 hours aren't really the target audience for games which focus on endgame raid dungeons which absolutely require a solid 4+ hour block of time.

  4. #24
    SuperKenshin's Servent Reputation: 47

    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Posts
    1,065
    Rep Power
    7

    Default

    To the above post...yes, fatigue "makes sense" on dungeon crawlers like C9, DN and these. But you forget something...it makes sense if you can only have ONE account or ONE character, otherwise it's pointless because people who wants to play 15 hours of farming a day will still achieve it by creating multiple accounts or characters.

    Fatigue system is not in place so you rush content at a slower pace, at least not in the west. The only purpose of fatigue is to not make people adicted to a game and force them to take breaks...something that may work for example in Korea since people probably can't make 20 accounts due to KSSN and verifications needed while here in the west having multiple accounts on a F2P game is quite common and simple to do.

    Games that have any sort of fatigue system pretty much come from Korea, not removing that feature for western versions is quite dumb imo as it makes no sense to have it.
    Last edited by Adamaris; 03-15-2013 at 08:29 PM.

Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 123

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •