The concept in general. Gamer meets gamer...it's love at first frag.
The banner is sexy, despite my hatred for WoW.
Though I would say the design is a bit over simplified, I'm certainly pleased you didn't over do it, throwing flash animations all over the place or those stupid animated cursors.
I like that you fit the site to an 800x600 form factor. This allows for people who don't have larger monitors, or are blind to view the site at a comfortable resolution. It also minimizes horizontal scrolling (which I loathe).
The forums seem pretty well laid out. Granted its a cooky cutter design, but that's sometiems the only thing that works. Also, the source code is pretty clean, though I'd have put the CSS into an intirely different file.
I like the concept of having a helper robot to show you the ropes.
The statistic sections are pretty neat. When I'm not on there blogging or whatever, I can look up some random facts.
What I didn't like:
Aside from the forums, the rest of the site was poorly written. It leads me to believe the creator used some kind of "click and go" web designing software. Great for making mock ups, but horrible for final versions (yes I know this is a beta). Messy code leads to slow execution.
Organization of the menus over all didn't seem like it was well thought out. What is the point of the tabs on the main page if you have the my account drop down menu? Speaking of extra menus, why does the home button have a drop down menu to begin with?
There's too much crap on the main page. I have to scroll down twice just to get the news. Shouldn't that be up top some where?
Isn't the color scheme kind of..well...dark? Neutral colors I get, but why so much black? Feels kind of emo to me.
As was mentioned before, this is just a beta, so hopefully things will look up later down the MMOFaces world.