I was wondering which one you think has better gameplay, graphics, combat, and which is more fun so far.
Printable View
I was wondering which one you think has better gameplay, graphics, combat, and which is more fun so far.
i like mabi graphic better and you can customize ur character in mabi better.
I need to try image now. Need to play it long enough to compare.
There's no point in comparing them right now since one is fully developed while the other is in closed beta. -_-
Omg you people must be possessed !!! a Vs topic for every damn game? come on now.... You probs heard someone say the fighting is like mabi and thought HEY lets compare them. even though the rest of the game doesnt play like mabi !
Plus ones in CB and been out for 3 days and ones been out for 4months. Just think before you post.
But to be on topic ! i didnt like either of them tbh. Not my type of game i guess.
obviously but you can still get a little comparison I mean graphics arnt gonna improve a sht load from closed to full game.
And gamplay doesnt change that much.
Well hmm..
Mabinogi says it's ABSOLUTELY FREE when it isn't
And Shin Megami Tensei, well, it's Shin Megami Tensei, I don't know what else to say.
SMT for life.
In content, gameplay, storyline, future content, etc etc. I think Mabi wins hands down. SMT is fun and all but it can't compare.
that depends on how cash shop based it's going to be. Mabi's a good game and all, but it requires alot of time, and it's VERY cash shop based.
Mabinogi all the way.
Mabinogi cuz the Combat is more "fluid" and u actually know what skill the monster is using in mabinogi, and cuz mabinogi is more challenging :/
As much as I love Imagine, I will say Mabinogi cause it have more content and gameplay is superior (In my opinion) Don't tell me its a closed beta...I played the japanese version of imagine too before so I know what i'm talking about.
I prefer SMT as Mabinogi makes my eyes bleed and was generally just an all round boring experience.
SMT my experience in JP version was WAY better than mabinogi
Dude your comparing a
FULLY RELEASED game too a -------> CB game.
Anyways in my japan SMT experience and mabin experience.
SMT>Mabin
G4is fully devoloped.. Hmm...
Anyways , mabinogi will beat imagine with its amount of things to do. Imagine and mabi should tie in quality.
Imagine is graphicly SUPPERIOR , and alot more customizable.
The features in imagine are alot more unique , like the demon system.
Combat is .. I'd still go with MABI.
All in all , there fairly equal I'd go with imagine myself , however Im having fun with mabi , so forget bout it.
I was expecting a thread of Mabi vs SMT was to be created soon.
Oh well, I vote for SMT since Mabi has an IP Block. :(
Mabi is in G3, SMT is in Beta.
Mabi is old, SMT is new OMG hype.
No point in the poll yet.
Okay so the combat is more challenging because you can see what skill the monster is using? That just makes it easy and less skill, but yeah you can see what skill a monster is using in Megaten because the way there acting. If there walking around you but don't attack you there defending, if they stand still and don't attack you there using counter etc etc... Same as mabinogi only mabinogi had to make even more easier. But yeah dungeons are tougher in mabinogi. At least early on.
I must say i like them both a lot, can't play mabinogi anymore. Thats too bad.
Sweet, look how much SMT is winning by
Well Nexon NA is hosting the game on their servers for free. Allowing you to try out about 90% of the game without having to pay at all.
If you really enjoy the game and can't afford it you could just buy NX from people or do those survey things. A friend of mine pays for his game entirely through the surveys. His total level is 344 and he has one of each pet. He hasn't spent a dime but he beat me in levels o.x