Can you learn to play guitar through a game?

I'm talking about games like Rock Band, Guitar Hero, Power Gig, etc. Do they legitimately teach you how to play a real guitar? I'm asking 'cuz I got a sudden random urge to learn how to play a guitar XD.

I'm sorry if this has been asked before, I searched but found nothing.

Yes. Yes they do.

Guitar Hero, no. The new Rock Band will have a "Pro Guitar" that has buttons in place of the strings, but looks like a failure. Pay for lessons if you want to get good. Internet tutorials are all-right but mostly useless.

Guitar hero and rockband have no strings on their guitars. Neither do they have the finger placement thingies (forgot what they're called).

Do the math.

I hear if you play Power Gig with your actual guitar, you'll learn how to play songs on advanced mode.

Sure just like Call of Duty teaches me how to be a real soldier.

Aw man w/e ill just use YouTube like every other wannabe LOL.

I'll never understand why people say that playing Guitar Hero on Expert is as hard as playing real guitar.

I've heard it said and it's not true.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Norrin Radd

I'll never understand why people say that playing Guitar Hero on Expert is as hard as playing real guitar.

I've heard it said and it's not true.

---

It's not even close.

Go to the Power Gig website>guitar>lessons. Some pretty easy to understand lessons. Cameraman suck balls though.

Where did you get this idea from....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cloud13

I will say that being awesome at Guitar Hero made it a whole lot easier to learn guitar, but in no way does it actually teach you.

---

this, it is a pretty fun way to stretch your fingers and get them used to swift motions if you wanna play lead or so. but thats just as easily done picking up a real guitar and doing some warm ups

actually....with rockband 3 you can...

http://www.rockband.com/blog/fender-squier-pictures

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cloud13

I will say that being awesome at Guitar Hero made it a whole lot easier to learn guitar, but in no way does it actually teach you.

---

I think just being musically inclined and having rhythm makes it easier to be good at real guitar and Guitar Hero. I don't think being good at Guitar Hero helps you learn guitar, unless you didn't know how to press with your fingers prior to playing the game XD

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CaptRex

No.. because there is no strings on video game.. If you really want to be a rocker, just go for the real guitar but if you are a poser, just keep playing your guitar hero :p

---

And even though it's been posted in here twice already, people still don't even seem to realize that yes, it does have strings, and it is a guitar. lawls

im sure it quickens the learning speed. XD

The last system I had was ps2, FYI.
But shouldnt the games with the real guitar help at least a little?

I thought the new guitar was suppose to allow you to use "6 string" and all the frets (just not physically being there). I could have been wrong, but if you r really looking for a game to do it, that might be your best option for you to start if you would rather do a game and not learn via a real guitar and tutor.