Wow, worst ratings ever given. See? You give dishonest ratings.
These sigs look not bad. You didn't even say why it was bad, also the 3rd one is already in his sig.
IMO it'd be better without the outer glow on text. Also once you get the background I think you should take out the grid(unless BG looks good with grid lines)
On the banner: There is some light that is blocking text and background which make it look bad.

