Now, I don't expect most people to know how to do that on this site. An frankly, I don't really either.

So, does anyone with a lil more knowledge know how to truly rate a mmorpg from 1 to 10?

sorta like a movie critic, so people can really get a grasp on the game. not just some lopsided fanboy review. you know what i mean by that.

like is this kinda how would you do it. or something of that sort. an how would you come to decide if it gets a 4 or an 8

graphics ++++
gameplay+++++
story++
controls+
community++