I like runescape, i replayed it a couple of months back. For runescape, it's not really about the graphics. it's more of the skills that's in the game. (firemaking, mining, tree cutting, smithing, if i am not wrong, 1 of the first to have such skills.)

It's all about preferences.. There's no right or wrong in this kind of stuff. Just that alot more people hates it doesn't mean it's a bad game.