All of you say WoW is horrible, and I am wondering how many of you have actually played it?
And actually, you are mistaken. The game came with a 30-day free trial to those who bought the game. That 30-days was later extended to 60, and then indefinitely. The negative reviews moved them to allow players to experience all of the updates before seriously committing to a game that would take so much time to enjoy. So technically, I think you still have to buy the game to play for free. So it is B2P? For now at least. Later on, probably on the release of the PS3 version it will not be B2P anymore, but B2P2P (Buy to Pay to Play).