Neither. Why? Because both "professional" and independent reviews are both opinion, and it's never good to just allow one person's opinion to control what you decide to do.
Tell me, if you like RPG games, and you read a "professional" review of an RPG by someone who doesn't like RPGs, and the end score suffers because the reviewer doesn't like RPGs, does that mean the RPG is bad?
Just because tons of independent say that Morrowind is the best video game ever even to this day and Oblivion/Skyrim are terrible, does that make it true?
What you're trying to do with this thread is ask why some reviews don't agree with your opinion of a game, and you have your answer in your question.
