rate my first sig

[crie]

my first sig, rate it

[Mystixs]

3/10
Not that great. But it is your first.

[GoFlyAKite]

Since it's your first, it's pretty good.

[Shadow of The Lost Empire]

... I... Think you might wanna take another whack at it...

[*Legend*]

Yeah, that's horrible, even for a first. Maybe you should read some tutorials before making something. It goes a very long way.

[*Legend*]

Alot of first sigs in this area have been good. Save a few Gimp signatures.
So that looks really bad compared to the other first sigs, that atleast looked like effort was put into them. =/

[SilverIce]

sorry man, but my eyes literally hurt looking at it. the pattern seriously makes me dizzy.

[GoFlyAKite]

What have I been smoking? Okay then, pull out someones first signature from here, they won't be pretty. I'll admit mine sucked, it looked like it was a paper bag. But in that topic everyone said it was good, because it was my first.

[*Legend*]

Ok. I'll pull a lot out, all guaranteed to put this in the dirt. =)

[GoFlyAKite]

Well, that's kind of obvious isn't it? You're going to take the ones better then this, and leave the rest. It would only be fair if you got even better and worse, I'd pick out the worse but I have dial-up. So, no. Oh, and maybe your first signature too? No cheating.

[*Legend*]

I actually didn't start with "All he did was just........", I started with "He probably just". I'm not much of a brainiac, so I can't tell you exactly what he did. He could've done more, or he could've done less for all I know. His signature just looks really, plain. Almost like something you can do in paint, up to the pattern overlay. And it aggravates me to see people say it's good, when it looks like he didn't try at all, I have no idea why though, that's why I made the suggestion to read a couple of tutorials first.

[Deathend]

My first was plain crap and I'm still crap since I don't even know hardly any of the sexy effects nor what most things in photoshop even do. Anyways a tutorial you might like is http://www.forum.curse-x.com/showthread.php?t=355 it's simple and it's shiny.. SHINY!

[GoFlyAKite]

When did I ever say that you said it was the best first signature.

The reason you wen't through all of the 'first' signatures was to prove that his wasn't the best 'first' signature, which I never said it was.

And no, I didn't grab out the "best signatures" because there weren't any bad signatures to begin with.

So you're saying, out of all of the 'first' signatures in this whole forum, there wasn't any bad ones? Yes you did grab the best signatures, because you wanted to prove a point.

I don't really care if you believe me or not, but if it makes you feel any smarter, maybe you should go search for some first sigs yourself.

Why would I need to feel smarter on a forum?

Also, if I told you your first sig was good, and told damn near everyone else their first sig was good, then they are good. And yes, I did. I said his first signature is horrible, because it is. I'm not going to lie to him.

I didn't say lie to him did I? It's called being easy, considering it's his first attempt at making one, and no, it's not going to be great, so don't rate it like he is a pro. at it.

And the reason I pmed you is not because I have something to hide, but it's to cause less friction.

That statement wasn't directed towards you, it was to anyone that was going to post, 'why don't you guys take it to PM's, nobody cares!'.

And dude, it's called the Library.

?

Anyways, I don't want to argue, making enemies on the internet is useless, plus you're cool.