I can't see why there are so many runescape haters out there its a great game, if you can make a better game w/ java and make millions off it pst me. Its one of the few that is updated alot and the updates bring more and more people back to it.
Back on topic: i really hated tibia didn't enjoy it at all. Also LoA disappointed me, i played for a while, but it was pure pot spamming in pvp and grind wasn't fun at all.