Depends who you talk to. Lots of people will say it sucked cause the beta had alot of bugs and wasn't a whole lot to do because you couldn't change jobs.
I loved the game though just on the potential and battle system. First closed beta just ended, and 2nd one should be starting sometime soon, and hopefully alot of bugs will be fixed and we can change jobs and such.
It's like a multiplayer snes rpg, which to me is pure win.